I have some ideas on why some people cling to this absurdity of Republicanism. But I'll save them for last. Let's first examine what Republicans stand for today as evidenced by their actions, not their words, which today are mostly untruths.
Not that my Democratic Party is anywhere near perfect. But it has most of the elements of a diversity of views on the social order, economics and democracy. It has a "left wing" such as Warren and the Squad. It has a pretty solid middle of those not ready for left wing reformation of our society and it has a semblance of a "right wing" supporting greater fiscal restraint than the left and a pretty unrestrained corporate economy and some elements of "traditional" social values such as hetero marriage, opposition to abortion and some skepticism about rapid social reforms.
Really, you don't see that diversity in the modern, post-Reagan Republican Party. I know, some of you prefer being an independent voter, seemingly not liking being tied to a fairly rigid set of values on governance and preferring a kind of cafeteria politics. But hey, if this works for you, stick with it though you risk being road kill as Jim Hightower likes to observe, saying nothing's in the middle of the road but yellow stripes and dead armadillos.
But as you might self examine about why you would call yourself a Republican, lets look at the actions in recent years, particularly the Trump years. As the Trump campaign was developing, some really observant players in the fringes of the Republican Party saw an opportunity; these were the hard core fascist White Nationalists like Bannon, Miller and Gorka. They are joined by less ideological but equally racist party actors. They insinuated themselves into the campaign and later administration leadership. They were joined by hard core libertarians deeply suspicious of a functioning government who were ready to undermine existing regulations and federal management of resources. Joining them too were the authoritarians who long identified with the Crown during our Revolution, States Rights during the post Civil War period and an Executive branch exercising greater power and authority than the legislature and legal branch of our federal system. Finally, the finance arm of the coalition consisted of Russiaphiles who admired the looting of the Soviet treasury/assets by oligarchs who saw much of that wealth invested in the U.S.A., including through the Trump organizations via the Russian Mob, still seeking new investment opportunities.
These factions joined together to seize the opportunity of a clearly incompetent, failed business guy whose only ideology, let alone reading was reported to be Mein Kampf on his bedside table. This was a guy with a very clear public record of sexually predatory behavior, business dishonesty and a huge, narcissistic ego and lust for power, not public service. A person with very visible ignorance about our democracy, our history and protocols and norms which enabled a mostly reasonable bipartisan governance. They saw an opportunity to manipulate him for their own clear ideological goals. This became the fascist coalition not unlike that formed in the 30's in Germany and Italy.
It is instructive to know that the Third Reich did not emerge by overthrowing a regime; Germany was an impressive democracy. Fascism grew over time with internal disruption of the laws, norms and processes to emerge in the ruins of that democracy.
This toxic stew combined with sufficient voter racism and economic neglect in a few battle ground states and with half the electorate just not engaged in the process at all gave us the most failed Presidency in the history of the Republic. And it gave us what may be a democracy virtually destroyed. It may be rebuilt over time, but the damage is horrific. Here is what we face.
A government structure at war with itself; not just in conflict and disagreement bridgeable by skillful negotiations as in the past. Flat out, three branches in a shooting war with one another.
We are in a full blown Constitutional crisis now because the separation of powers have been abandoned by both the Republican legislative minority and the ruling Executive Branch. This is best exemplified in the Executive ignoring both requests and subpoenas lawfully and Constitutionally originating in the Legislative branch. The governing consensus is now broken. If the separation of powers is not upheld, we have lost our democracy and we are in an authoritarian state.
An executive branch with now an authoritarian fascist comportment, having gone through the Bannon lead deconstruction of most of the regulatory policies they administer, deliberate staffing shortfalls to assure dysfunction if not failure. And the abandonment of norms and non-binding traditions of governing cooperation and respect for the co-equal status of the the other branches.
A policy and practice to marginalize vulnerable groups such as Muslims and Hispanic migrants, Jews, African Americans, disabled and LGBTQ persons much in the fashion of the Third Reich.
The escalation of detention camps filled with migrants from our south, many of whom have been denied lawful consideration of their distressed immigration status. This includes the current 5,700 migrant children ripped from their families and held in unhealthy, inhumane and physically and emotionally damaging circumstances.
A practice of exploiting ignorant, bigoted and racist people with rallies inciting hate, violence, threatening and demeaning rhetoric in the fashion of the Nuremberg rallies in the Nazi era of Germany.
A steady stream of social media Tweets inciting hate, violence and demeaning rhetoric against any criticism of him.
A blatant abuse of Executive power together with open self dealing corruption, also permitted by Cabinet members.
The use of the Justice Department to avenge perceived wrongs to the President by both Administration appointees and partisan opponents. Also the denigration of FBI, CIA and National Security professionals deemed critical of Administration policy and practice.
Undermining the Constitutionally required Congressional oversight of the Executive branch.
The filling of Judicial branch appointments with right wing ideologues rather than the careful vetting of liberal, moderate and conservative jurists for proper educational and judicial experience.
The overwhelming abdication of their oaths of office to defend the Constitution from wrong doing by the Executive by most Republican members of Congress strictly for purposes of their own political self preservation and reelection.
Gone is the mostly mythological dedication of the Republican Party to fiscal responsibility, given the current historically massive national debt and irresponsible fiscal management to loot our treasury with benefactors being the wealthiest few among us.
The alienation and outright insults directed at our allies around the world who relied on us for sound, measured and prudent leadership in world affairs.
Finally, totally ignoring the most egregious malfeasance in ignoring the impending disaster of climate change which threatens the planet's very habitability. All the aforementioned insults to our democracy pale by comparison to this catastrophic neglect.
So, what would compel one to nonetheless declare oneself a Republican given this factual evidence?
A better economy? The growth and economic health data suggests we are no better off in many sectors of the economy than the latter part of the previous Democratic Administration and are significantly experiencing negative numbers in the trade, agriculture and manufacturing sectors. And there are signs of an impending recession next year.
Possibly your economic fortunes have shown great improvement in the past few years, but do the policies and actions of the Trump Administration account for that, or the natural arc of your fortunes?
Looking outside your bubble, the evidence suggests our collective fortunes are not having the same experience.
If not economic improvement, what then explains the 80% of Republicans still approving of Trump's leadership? Improvement in the social order? Really? Cite me an example beyond perhaps improvement in your own social status or advancement. Our society is more polarized than in any period since the Civil War by any measurement. Hate crimes are on the rise. Mass shootings are ascendant. Many people, especially Trumpites live in hate and now overt public expressions of bigotry. Migrants and people of color are fearful. Children are traumatized with school drills preparing for mass shootings. Whistle blowers are fearful of losing their protection. Voters wonder if they will be denied their right to vote or their vote properly counted. Our international allies are now doubtful of our reliability as a partner in dealing with crises. Extreme weather events are increasing.
Housing is becoming unaffordable. Employment is insecure and safety nets are uncertain. Healthcare costs are escalating and many more are without health insurance. Post high school education costs are through the roof and driving many into a lifetime of debt. Infamous American optimism is in decline. So where is the improvement?
Are the Republicans offering any solutions? Are they putting country over self or Party? Name a solution that redeems this litany of Republican betrayal of American values and advancement of the American dream? Name just one solution?
I can only speculate on why anyone would remain a supporter of Trump if not for their inability to relate outside of their life bubble; I'm okay and don't give a damn about anyone else? Maybe that is it. Or fear that your okay will be disrupted by "other" people foreign to your experience? Or maybe it is racism and the fear that in a decade or two, your white self will move from majority to minority in America? I am at a total loss to understand any other motivation that would explain why maybe 30% of the population will stick with this horror show. Maybe you have an idea? Let me know.
Please understand that this era is not normal. This is not routine American disagreement between liberals and conservatives, Republicans and Democrats. Brothers and sisters. Parents and their offspring. This is an existential threat to the great American experiment of democracy, small d. This is a civil war without bullets. It will require engagement of most Americans to restore the rule of law and work in their communities to rebuild a once great, though flawed democracy.
This is not a religion where you put your faith in the unknowable future. This is not a TV reality show, though it is treated as such by our President. This is a question of hard facts, data and a rational examination of the meaning and consequences of factual reality. If you are honest with yourself and willing to declare yourself in community with your fellow Americans, outside your own bubble, caring just some about the common good, you simply have to reject the current Republican paradigm and renounce you prior allegiance to Trumpism which has created the current American tragedy.